Skip to Content Area

Commissioner’s Bulletin # B-0047-07

November 14, 2007

TO: ALL INSURANCE COMPANIES, CORPORATIONS, EXCHANGES, MUTUALS, RECIPROCALS, ASSOCIATIONS, LLOYDS, OR OTHER INSURERS WRITING WORKERS' COMPENSATION AND EMPLOYERS' LIABILITY INSURANCE IN THE STATE OF TEXAS, THEIR AGENTS AND REPRESENTATIVES, AND TO THE PUBLIC GENERALLY.

RE: REVISED WORKERS' COMPENSATION CLASSIFICATION RELATIVITIES AND A REVISED TABLE OF EXPECTED LOSS RATES AND DISCOUNT RATIOS UPDATING THE TEXAS BASIC MANUAL OF RULES, CLASSIFICATIONS AND EXPERIENCE RATING PLAN FOR WORKERS' COMPENSATION AND EMPLOYERS' LIABILITY INSURANCE.

By Commissioner's Order No. 07-0915, the Commissioner of Insurance has adopted revised Texas Workers' Compensation Classification Relativities (classification relativities) and a revised table concerning the Expected Loss Rates and Discount Ratios by classification used in experience rating, which is contained in the Texas Basic Manual of Rules, Classifications, and Experience Rating Plan for Workers' Compensation and Employers' Liability Insurance.

The Commissioner's Order can be viewed at http://www.tdi.state.tx.us/orders/index.html by clicking on Order No. 07-0915.

Summary Checklists of Required Submissions from Insurers

For insurers with no change in their filed deviation or a change in their filed deviation to make the adopted revised relativities revenue neutral:

For insurers with a change in their filed deviation:

Pursuant to Insurance Code Article 5.96 and Chapter 2053, each workers' compensation insurer must either adopt the revised classification relativities or file its own insurer-specific classification relativities.

Section 2053.003 requires each insurer to file with the Texas Department of Insurance (Department) all rates, supplementary rating information, and reasonable and pertinent supporting information for risks written in this state. Accordingly, each workers' compensation insurer changing its filed deviation following the adoption of the revised classification relativities and expected loss rates must make a submission to the Department.

Workers' compensation insurers with no changes in their filed deviations or changes in their filed deviations to make the adopted revised classification relativities revenue neutral must submit information indicating this.

The attached Notice of Carrier Intent and Certification, as well as the Transmittal Form and filing forms and materials in the Filings Made Easy Guide, available at 28 TAC §§5.9310, 5.9340-5.9342, are provided to assist insurers in submitting information and filings. The information may also be provided in insurer forms and formats.

Description of the Changes and Rate Level Impact

The classification relativities have been decreased by an average of 7.7% overall from the March 1, 2007 level. The classification relativities were reduced from 65% of the overall average level of the 1994 classification relativities to 60% of the 1994 classification relativities. The classification relativity change of any given classification is limited to +/- 25% prior to the adjustment to reduce the classification relativities to 60% of the 1994 classification relativities. After adjustment, the classification relativity change of any given classification is limited to +15.4% and -30.8% of the March 1, 2007 level.

The expected loss rates have decreased by an average of 21.7% overall from the March 1, 2007 level based on the latest statewide distribution of business by classification. Changes in individual expected loss rates were limited to +/- 25%. The maximum impact will be for larger risks in classes in which the expected loss rate decreased by 25%. In those cases, the experience modifier may increase by as much as 33%. In instances in which the expected loss rate increased by 25%, the experience modifier may decrease by as much as 20%.

The discount ratios were revised to reflect the change in the size of claims and benefit levels over time. The overall level of the discount ratios did not change. Changes for an individual classification may affect the split between primary and excess losses.

Actions by Insurers

Pursuant to Insurance Code Chapter 2053, insurers must either adopt the revised classification relativities adopted by Commissioner's Order No. 07-0915 or file their own insurer-specific classification relativities for all workers' compensation policies written with an effective date on or after January 1, 2008. Pursuant to Commissioner's Order No. 07-0915, for policies with an effective date on or after January 1, 2008, insurers may no longer use the March 1, 2007 classification relativities as the basis of their rates. All rates must be based either on the January 1, 2008 classification relativities or on insurer-specific classification relativities that have been filed with the Department. Insurers that currently have insurer-specific classification relativities on file with the Department must also use the revised January 1, 2008 classification relativities or make a new filing of insurer-specific classification relativities. Insurers may use the new classification relativities prior to January 1, 2008, provided they notify the Department before the selected effective date for the new classification relativities.

Insurers currently writing workers' compensation insurance that plan to continue writing that coverage on or after January 1, 2008, must send their submissions to the Department before January 1, 2008. Insurers that are not currently writing workers' compensation insurance but plan to write their first policy with an effective date on or after January 1, 2008, must send their submissions to the Department before the effective date of their first policy.

Pursuant to Insurance Code Chapter 2053, the revised expected loss rates and discount ratios must be used to calculate experience modifiers with an effective date on or after January 1, 2008. They may not be used to calculate an experience modifier with an effective date prior to January 1, 2008.

Copies of the tables of revised classification relativities, expected loss rates, and discount ratios are available for download at the Department's website: www.tdi.state.tx.us. (Look for Commissioner's Bulletin No. B-0047-07 under Bulletins in the Lookup/Search section of the Department's home page.) The tables are available in Excel and PDF formats.

Required Submissions from Insurers

If an insurer does not wish to change its deviations, it must complete the attached Notice of Carrier Intent and Certification and the Transmittal Form from the Filings Made Easy Guide to confirm the date that it will start using the new classification relativities (must be no later than January 1, 2008). The Notice of Carrier Intent and Certification for insurers currently writing workers' compensation coverage should be filled out completely even if the insurer has no change in its deviation or if no deviation exists. Such a submission will not be considered a rate filing under Insurance Code §2053.003.

If an insurer wishes to achieve revenue neutrality, it may also adjust its existing deviation so that the introduction of the January 1, 2008 relativities is revenue neutral based on the insurer's own distribution of business by classification. Insurers adopting this approach should clearly indicate so in a cover letter and include as a separate exhibit a listing by classification of the March 1, 2007 and January 1, 2008 relativities and the most recently available payrolls by classification. An average of the sets of relativities weighted by the payrolls should also be included in the exhibit. Such a submission will not be considered a rate filing under Insurance Code §2053.003.

If an insurer elects to change its deviations for reasons other than to achieve revenue neutrality (even if for only one class), the insurer must comply with the instructions for rate changes provided in the Filings Made Easy Guide. The insurer should also complete and include the attached Notice of Carrier Intent and Certification with the rate filing. Such a submission will be considered a rate filing under Insurance Code §2053.003.

Insurers that are not currently writing workers' compensation insurance but plan to write their first policy with an effective date on or after January 1, 2008, must comply with the instructions for rate changes provided in the Filings Made Easy Guide.

Noncompliance

Failure of insurers to adopt the revised classification relativities and the uniform experience rating plan or file their own insurer-specific classification relativities for all workers' compensation policies written with an effective date on or after January 1, 2008, may constitute a violation of the Insurance Code and/or Title 28 of the Administrative Code and may subject the insurer to penalties provided by law.

Where to Send Submissions

All submissions should be sent to:

Texas Department of Insurance

Property and Casualty Intake Unit (MC 104-3B)

P. O. Box 149104

Austin, TX 78714-9104

Forms and Exhibits

Filing requirements are specified in the Property and Casualty Filings Made Easy Guide at: http://www.tdi.state.tx.us/company/rspceasy.html. Unless an insurer is changing its deviation, no other forms or other exhibits listed in the Filings Made Easy Guide, other than the Transmittal Form, need to be included in the filing.

The following documents may be downloaded from the Department's website:

If you are unable to download the exhibits, hard copies can be requested. Contact Dolores Thompson in the Property and Casualty Actuarial Division at 512-475-3017 or by e-mail at pcactuarial@tdi.state.tx.us.

Department Contact

For further information or questions concerning this bulletin, please contact Elizabeth Buhro in the Property and Casualty Actuarial Division at 512-305-6747 or by e-mail at elizabeth.buhro@tdi.state.tx.us.

J'ne Byckovski

Chief Actuary

Property and Casualty Actuarial Division

Attachment: Notice of Carrier Intent and Certification

The Sunset Review of the Texas Department of Insurance

Exhibit A & B

Exhibit C





For more information, contact:


Remember: TDI's Internet resources are to be used for legitimate state purposes. Occasional personal use is permitted so long as such use is incidental, is brief, does not result in additional cost to TDI or the state and does not interfere with the performance of the employee's job duties. Under no circumstances may an employee use TDI's Internet resources to access sexual, offensive, profane or otherwise inappropriate information. By using TDI computers to access Internet resources, TDI employees are consenting to the monitoring of their use of Internet resources. TDI employees do not have a privacy interest or an expectation of privacy in the use of TDI computers to access Internet resources. Refer to the TDI Operations Manual for additional information.